Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin
Metacritic
OpenCritic
Mighty
IGDB
Players
OpenCritic Score
Score Distribution
"Players who have played Dark Souls II for an extended period, as well as all of the DLC may find that the rearranged enemy and item placement enough to get them fighting for their soul once again, but only if they are die-hard fans. If you haven't played the original or you were stopped a bit short the first time around, Scholar of the First Sin is the perfect excuse to come back and try your hand at the experience again. The new additions and visual upgrades make this the best version to play the game on. "
Finding live streams...
About Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin
FromSoftware released Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin on April 2, 2015. This edition bundles all three DLC expansions while upgrading graphics and performance across PC, PlayStation, and Xbox consoles. The game drops players into a dying world filled with rotting kings and twisted magic. You navigate interconnected zones where every corner holds a trap or a hidden weapon. The core loop involves exploring these ruins, defeating massive bosses, and slowly uncovering the lore through item descriptions rather than cutscenes. It remains one of the toughest action RPGs on the market, demanding patience and precise timing from anyone who picks it up today.
Gameplay
You control a customizable character moving through a large kingdom filled with traps and ambushes. Combat relies on stamina management where you must time your dodges and attacks carefully. Every enemy placement has been shifted in this version to create new challenges. You can summon other players for co-op help or invade their worlds as an invader. Battles often last several minutes of intense back-and-forth exchanges where one mistake leads to death. The game tracks 38 achievements, though only 35.4% of players unlock them on average. You spend most of your time managing equipment, upgrading stats, and learning enemy patterns. A typical session involves dying repeatedly until you finally clear a difficult boss or find a shortcut that saves time later.
What Players Think
Critics praise this edition heavily with an 87 score on OpenCritic where 88.64% of reviewers recommend it. Metacritic sits at 79 while IGDB rates it 85.2 based on 432 ratings. Players describe the mood as strategic and story-driven despite some mixed feelings on the original game's pacing. Digital Spy gave a perfect score, noting that new enemy placements and improved visuals make this the definitive version. Daily Mirror called it a nightmare worth having for those returning to the series. The community finds the achievements challenging since the rarest one, "The Dark Soul," unlocks at only 5.90%. Most players report long playtimes due to the sheer amount of content packed into the full package including all DLCs.
PlayPile's Take
This game is for players who want a brutal challenge and do not mind dying constantly. It costs $26.99 currently with a historical low of $19.95 available on GameBillet. The 38 achievements provide a long-term goal, though the low unlock rate suggests high difficulty. You should buy this if you missed the original or want the best version of the sequel. Avoid it if you prefer linear stories or fast-paced action without punishment. The rebalanced bosses and added NPCs make the experience feel fresh compared to earlier releases. It stands as a complete package for those willing to suffer through its unforgiving mechanics.
Game Modes
Single player, Multiplayer, Co-operative
IGDB Rating
85.2
RAWG Rating
4.2
Deals
Finding deals...
Videos
2Annoucement Trailer
Screenshots
10Community Moods
Achievements
Loading achievements...
Similar Games
Finding similar games...
Buzzing on Bluesky
Checking Bluesky...
