Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments
IGDB
Players
Loading critic reviews...
Finding live streams...
About Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments
Frogwares released this detective adventure in late 2014 after their previous title failed to capture the public imagination. You play as Sherlock Holmes across six distinct cases ranging from murders to disappearances and thefts. The game launched on PC, PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, and later ports to Switch and newer consoles. Focus Entertainment handled the publishing duties for this standalone entry in the series. It leans heavily on the original Conan Doyle stories while adding a modern twist where your choices alter the narrative outcome. You investigate crime scenes without a direct combat system to distract you from the deduction work.
Gameplay
You spend most of your time examining evidence at various locations using magnifying glasses and logical tools. The interface lets you interact with objects, collect clues, and build a web of connections between suspects and events. Each case allows you to pursue multiple leads simultaneously until you have enough proof to solve the mystery. Your moral decisions during interrogations affect Holmes reputation and change how characters treat you later in the story. The game does not force a linear path so you can choose when to confront a suspect or gather more information. Sessions feel slow and deliberate as you piece together timelines and alibis before making an accusation.
What Players Think
PlayPile members have rated this title 77.2 out of 100 based on 183 reviews on IGDB. Average playtime sits around 15 hours for a standard run through the six cases. The community mood leans toward appreciation for the atmosphere but criticism for repetitive investigation mechanics. Players note that completion rates drop significantly after the first three stories due to pacing issues. Review snippets frequently mention the freedom of choice as the strongest point despite occasional confusing clue systems. Some users spent over 20 hours trying to find every secret ending and achievement. The score reflects a game that is solid but not without noticeable flaws in its design.
PlayPile's Take
This title works best for players who enjoy methodical puzzle solving over action sequences. The single player mode offers enough variety in cases to keep interest alive for roughly 15 hours. You can buy the game at a low price on most platforms including Switch and PC. Achievements exist but they do not require multiple playthroughs since choices are often forgiving. Avoid this if you need constant feedback or fast pacing. The investigation tools feel dated compared to modern standards even if the mystery structure holds up well.
Game Modes
Single player
IGDB Rating
77.2
Deals
Finding deals...
Videos
4E3 Trailer
Release Date Trailer
Trailer
Screenshots
5Achievements
Loading achievements...
Similar Games
Finding similar games...
Buzzing on Bluesky
Checking Bluesky...