Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments
IGDB
Loading critic reviews...
Finding live streams...
About Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments is a single-player adventure puzzle game from Frogwares that drops you into the iconic detective’s shoes. Released in 2014, it spans PC and major consoles, offering six distinct cases ranging from murders to supernatural mysteries. You gather evidence, interrogate witnesses, and solve logic-heavy puzzles to crack cases, with your choices affecting outcomes and Holmes’s reputation. The game leans heavily into Conan Doyle’s lore, blending deduction with moral dilemmas. It’s a niche pick for fans of cerebral mysteries and Holmes’ world, though its outdated visuals and gameplay quirks might not convert casual players.
Gameplay
The core loop revolves around exploration and deduction. You start each case by collecting physical clues, bloodstains, footprints, hidden notes, then cross-reference them with witness interviews. Puzzles often require linking seemingly unrelated evidence, like using a suspect’s alibi to unlock a locked room. The interface feels clunky by modern standards, with a magnifying glass mechanic that drags your cursor over hotspots. Dialogue trees force you to pick questions that reveal hidden truths, while your answers to suspects’ statements directly influence case outcomes. Each case clocks in around 3-4 hours, but backtracking to missed clues can eat time. The puzzles are clever but grind-heavy, rewarding obsessive attention to detail over action or speed.
What Players Think
The game holds a 77.2/100 IGDB score with 183 ratings, averaging 67% positive and 33% negative. Playtime data shows 60% of players finish in under 15 hours, with 33% hitting 100% completion. Community moods are split: 54% enjoyment, 28% frustration, and 18% boredom. Reviewers praise the “authentic Holmes vibes” and “rewarding deduction,” while criticizes “repetitive puzzle design” and “awkward camera angles.” One user called it “a love letter to Doyle’s legacy,” while another griped about “1920s-era UI.” The 15 achievements are mostly clue-finding and puzzle-solving tasks, with a 68% completion rate for top achievements.
PlayPile's Take
Crimes & Punishments is a double-edged sword: it’s faithful to Holmes’ methodical style but lacks polish. Price is variable, often around $10-20 on sales, making it a low-risk try for mystery fans. The 15 achievements and 33% completion rate suggest it’s challenging but not impossible. It thrives as a niche pick for those who crave slow-burn detective work over flashy action. Skip if you dislike rigid puzzle logic or outdated interfaces. For Holmes purists, though, the cases offer a worthy, if flawed, tribute.
Game Modes
Single player
IGDB Rating
77.2
Deals
Finding deals...
Videos
4E3 Trailer
Release Date Trailer
Trailer
Screenshots
5Achievements
Loading achievements...
Similar Games
Finding similar games...
Buzzing on Bluesky
Checking Bluesky...