Loading critic reviews...
Finding live streams...
About The Tooth Fae
The Tooth Fae is a bizarre simulator where you play a creepy nighttime intruder stealing teeth from unsuspecting victims. Developed by solo creator Ev, it launched in October 2025 as an expanded version of a Ludum Dare prototype. The game blends stealth, resource management, and slapstick horror as you navigate homes under cover of darkness. Its intentionally unsettling tone and minimalist design lean into dark humor, making it a polarizing but memorable oddity. The PC and web-friendly format keeps it accessible, though the short play sessions and quirky mechanics mean it’s not for everyone. Think of it as a twisted take on household invasion, with a focus on absurdity over polish.
Gameplay
Each run starts with you equipping tools like a flashlight and pliers to breach homes. You crawl through vents or open windows, avoiding pets and family members while snatching teeth. The core loop involves balancing stealth (no noise), timing (avoid patrols), and efficiency (collect high-value teeth). Mini-games pop up, like dodging a pet’s tail or solving a lock puzzle, which can feel clunky but amplify the chaos. Controls are basic but responsive, with quick-time events adding tension. Sessions rarely last past 15 minutes, especially if you get caught or the family wakes up. The game’s charm lies in its grotesque humor and the surreal satisfaction of escaping with a handful of pearly whites.
What Players Think
Community ratings average 7.6/10, with critics at 82/100. 68% of players finish the game, but 32% quit early. Average playtime is 4.2 hours, and 45% of community moods are labeled "Amused," while 30% are "Annoyed." Many praise the game’s audacity and dark comedy, calling it "a twisted guilty pleasure" (Review #124). Others gripe about repetitive mechanics and glitchy mini-games, like one player noting "the cat chase sequence is pure punishment" (Review #789). The 15 achievements focus on stealthy milestones (e.g., "Steal 50 Teeth Without Getting Caught") but rarely entice full completion.
PlayPile's Take
The Tooth Fae is a niche pick for fans of absurdist stealth and black comedy. At $14.99, it’s a low-risk purchase if you’re curious about its gross-out humor and intentionally jagged edges. The 15 achievements add light replay value but won’t hook you long-term. Skip this if you want depth or polish. For under an hour, it’s a weirdly satisfying diversion, like a horror-themed version of Stardew Valley, but with more screaming and fewer carrots. Not a classic, but a weirdly memorable one.
Game Modes
Single player
Deals
Finding deals...
Achievements
Loading achievements...
Similar Games
Finding similar games...
Buzzing on Bluesky
Checking Bluesky...